How to Properly Exchange Butter for Oil, and Oil for Butter in Recipes

Butter and oil are essential ingredients in cooking, and it’s entirely feasible to interchange them when you’re short on one. However, the trick lies in mastering the correct substitution technique. Continue reading to learn more!

Oil serves to enhance both the texture and flavor of dishes, whereas butter can alter the texture and taste of baked goods. The question then arises: can butter be swapped for oil and vice versa?

The concise response is yes, but it’s crucial to do it correctly.

This piece will guide you through the process of substituting butter for oil accurately, and the other way around.

Let’s begin by understanding how to replace oil with butter in your baking endeavors.

How to Substitute Butter for Oil in Baking

The process of substituting butter for oil in baking is straightforward.

Here are the key points to remember when substituting butter for oil:

– Use a 1:1 ratio, meaning replace the oil quantity specified in the recipe with the same amount of butter.
– This substitution applies whether the recipe calls for olive, canola, vegetable, or coconut oil.
– Be aware that butter imparts a distinct flavor, which might make you prefer it over oil.
– Always melt the butter before incorporating it into your recipes, allowing it to cool to room temperature first.
– Add the melted butter to your mixture at the same stage you would normally add oil.
– When using butter in cake recipes, you might notice increased moisture due to the water and milk content in butter, which also contributes a richer flavor to the crumb.
– If you’re making a larger quantity of cake, consider reducing the liquid in the recipe slightly to balance the extra moisture from the butter.
– For chiffon cakes, incorporate the melted butter into the batter carefully, and then fold in the beaten eggs.
– To enhance the flavor of your cake, consider adding vanilla extract, fresh spices, or cocoa powder.
– Note that butter is not suitable for those following a dairy-free diet.

In the following section, we’ll explore using butter in cooking methods that typically use oil.

How to Use Butter in Other Oil Cooking Techniques

Butter can also be a substitute for oil in various cooking techniques beyond baking.

Let’s delve into how to use butter in sautéing or pan-frying.

Sautéing or Panfrying

When sautéing items like shrimp or vegetables, butter can be used in place of oil. Here’s what to do:

1. Heat the pan, add the butter, and wait for it to bubble.
2. Let the butter melt completely over low heat.
3. Proceed with adding the other ingredients as per your recipe.

Next, we’ll look at how to employ butter in stir-frying.


You can use butter instead of oil in stir-frying, but avoid regular butter due to its low heat tolerance. Opt for clarified butter or ghee.

Now, let’s consider using butter for roasting.


Butter can be used to achieve a unique flavor when roasting. However, use clarified butter or ghee, as regular butter cannot withstand high heat.

Mixing butter with oil can be an effective solution when you’re low on cooking oil or desire the flavor of butter in your meals but still need the high-temperature resistance of oil. Add butter to the pan after the oil has heated to preserve its flavor.

Next, we’ll discover how to substitute oil for butter.

Can You Substitute Oil for Butter?

Yes, it’s possible to replace butter with oil in certain recipes, such as cookies. However, it’s important to understand the properties and characteristics of the oil you’re using before making the switch.

When substituting oil for butter, consider the type of oil: whether it’s highly saturated or unsaturated, or refined versus unrefined.

This section will cover each type of cooking oil to guide your substitution choice.

Highly Saturated Oil vs. Highly Unsaturated Oil

Highly saturated oils like palm and coconut oil solidify at lower temperatures, mimicking the solidifying properties of butter. In contrast, highly unsaturated oils, which include vegetable, olive, canola, flaxseed, and avocado oil, remain liquid at low temperatures and contain low levels of saturated fats. They are versatile for various recipes.

Refined Oil vs. Unrefined Oil

The refining process produces a neutral flavor or makes the oil more stable at high temperatures. The smoke point is a critical aspect to consider, as oils with a low smoke point can burn easily when heated too much. Refined oils, on the other hand, typically have a higher smoke point and are better suited for cooking. Keep in mind that the smoke point varies among different oil types.

Unrefined oils retain the flavor of their source plant, such as a coconut flavor in coconut oil or a nutty flavor in walnut oil. Refined oils are neutral in taste due to the removal of natural flavors and scents during refining.

Substituting Oil for Butter

There are scenarios where substituting oil for butter may be considered, such

as in the following:

– Cookies: While butter provides a unique taste and texture, oil can be used instead to create a softer and chewier cookie.
– Dairy-free diets: Those following a dairy-free diet can use oil as a butter alternative.
– Health considerations: Some may choose oil over butter due to cholesterol or saturated fat concerns.

In conclusion, while butter and oil can be interchanged in many recipes, keep in mind their distinct properties and the impact on the finished dish. Experiment with both to discover which you prefer in different cooking situations.

Leave a Comment